
Source: rasekhoon.net
You bade according to narration from the book ‘’ Fath al-Bari’’
‘’People that attended Jamal, Sefin and Nahrovan wars and believed that Ali was not right were Naseby’’.
Did Ayeshe that attended Jamal War believe that she was right or Hazrat Ali (peace be upon him)? If Ayeshe had not been right, why would she have gone from Mecca to Medina? Why were Talhe and Zobayr with her? Why was Abdullah Ben Zobayr with her? All of them are Naseby and you mentioned the name of Ebn Teimie. Didn’t Ebn Teimie talk in the favor of Yazid Ben Moavie, the leader of the faithful? Didn’t Suadii (you mentioned his name) publish a million books in the name of the leader of the faithful, Yazid Ben Moavie? Didn’t Malek Abdullah order to remove the black flag in the Moharam month of this year in Ghatif and Ahsa cities of Arab?
Then you bade that the prophet (peace of Allah be upon him and his descendants) said about Imam Hasan (peace be upon him) and Imam Hussein (peace be upon him)
و أما الحسن فإنه إبني و ولدي و مني سيد شباب أهل الجنة و حجة الله علي الأمة، قوله قولي و فعله فعلي، من تبعه فإنه مني و من عصاه فليس مني.
I should say whatever the prophet (peace of Allah be upon him and his descendants) was said as revelation (whether in saying or in acting).
Does this (وَ مَا يَنْطِقُ عَنِ الْهَوَي / إِنْ هُوَ إِلَّا وَحْيٌ يُوحَي) is related to the above narration?
Did a person that shot the corpse of Imam Hasan (peace be upon him) was Naseby or not? Ebn Abasi said to Ayeshe (even the Sunni scientists said a story about him)
تجملت تبغلت و إن عشت تفيلت.
Isn’t he (EbN Absi) Naseby?
The prophet (peace of Allah be upon him and his descendants) bade
يا علي! محبك طاهر الولادة و مبغضك خبيث الولادة.
When Ayeshe was informed in Medina that Hazrat Ali’s crown (peace be upon him) was cut in Kufe, why did she call Abdolrahman, Abdolrahman? Who informed her (Ayeshe) about this news? When Om Salame and Zeinab objected him, what did she answer them?
You bade ‘’ the time of hiding our religion has been passed ‘’and I agree that the time of hiding our religion has been passed. Is such a thing our right? Why should we forgive Ayeshe? Because she acted impertinently toward the prophet (peace of Allah be upon him and his descendants), Hazrat Ali (peace be upon him) and the corpse of Imam Hasan (peace be upon him)? And even I have heard in the Shiite narrations that Ayeshe got happy when the house of Hazrat Fateme Zahra (peace be unto her) was invaded.
It has been narrated
لا يجوز الغيبة، إلا غيبة الفاسق.
You watch the programs of the channel ‘’guardianship’’ that are related to the immaculate and innocent Imams. I do not care about who runs the channel ‘’ the prophet’s family’’ (he is a clergyman that wears turban on his head and you are Moslem cleric and wear turban on your head). You said ‘’ the person in charge of the channel ‘’ the prophet’s family’’ did not care about your request (my program should not be broadcasted on this channel)’’, but we never heard that he said such a remark (his indifference to your remark). Is this back biting or not? And it has been said such a thing in the martyr night of Imam Sajad (peace be upon him). These are not in the favor of none of us for God’s sake. You know the unbeliever person that invaded to Imam Zaman with a sword. I myself heard in the channel ‘’ Nur’’ that he considered the immaculate and innocent Imams with animals in an equal level from the point of view of immaculateness. We have not reacted to them and let them say whatever they like and we have struggle with each other. . و الله العلي العظيم!
You and I will be responsible against Hazrat Fateme Zahra (peace unto her) in the doomsday. I am surprised that you mentioned the name of the young Sheikh (it is not important whether he is literate or illiterate) that lives abroad and defends the prophet’s family (peace be upon them). Were Abu Bakr and Omar Nasebi against Imam Ali (peace be upon him)? Was Ayeshe Naseby against Imam Ali (peace be upon him)?
Answer 7
No, you تصحيف كرديد my statement. My statement was that he said
النواصب الزاعمين أن عليا لم يكن مصيبا في حروبه
‘’Naseby people believed that Imam Ali (peace be upon him) was not right and did wrongs in Jamal, Sefin and Khavarej Wars’’.
This is a question that you should answer. Although Ebn Asghalani is from you, you defend Ayeshe.
We do not consider them Naseby and we disagree with your idea and we do not accept your remarks. Ninety percent of your remarks are false in our opinion although you tried to present a complicated argument and we do not consider Ayeshe, Talhe and Zobayr Naseby. We think that Hazrat Ali is right and they are false. We also act to the narrations that the prophet (peace of Allah be upon him and his descendants) said to Ghasetin, Marghin and Nakesin about the leader of the faithful (peace be upon him) and we express realities. People should judge about the outcome of these matters. We do not care about whether the international channel ‘’ guardianship’’ acts impertinently toward the Sunnite and the holy things of the Sunnite or other channels. If the international channel ‘’ guardianship’’ insults the holy things of the Sunnite, I, as the manager of this channel, declares the disruption of this channel and I stop having any kind of cooperation with this channel. At the present, we cannot make the Shiite people be killed with the bullets of Vahabiat because we want to defend the prophet’s family (peace be upon them). We receive a lot of short messages about Ebn Hajar Asghalani. I wanted to say such matters many times ago, but such discussions have made me tell them today. I request the Sunni scientists that do not want us to tell them to stop insulting the Sunnite and the holy things of the Sunnite. The manager of the channel ‘’ the prophet’s family ’’ never listens to us and he also acts impertinently toward us and others. Even if an authority issues fatwa against them (the persons in charge of the channel ‘’ the prophet’s family’’), they will act impertinently toward him. We are worried about this channel because it makes riot. Even if the channel ‘’ guardianship’’ does such insults, we will say that the channel ‘’ guardianship’’ makes riot. If one of our experts wants to act impertinently toward the Sunnis, we will say that this expert makes riot. We do not care about what channel or who insults the Sunnite. Some people said some useless remarks in the media of the Islamic republic system of Iran and we criticized about them. At the present, we think that making disagreement between the Shiite and Sunni people (it does not matter what reasons it may be) is betrayal to the Islam and the Quran. They burnt our Quran and ridiculed at our holy things. But we celebrate for the death of Ayeshe! What were its consequences? When several irresponsible people celebrated in London, what were its consequences? Was it against the Shiite or in the favor of the Shiite? They provoked the channels and the people against the Shiite and increased animosity between the Shiite and Sunni people.
We are right about our ideas and defend from the prophet’s family (peace be upon them) and the leader of the faithful (peace be upon him) and we narrate about the caliphs from whatever there are in their books. Our friends talked about Ayeshe in detail, but they did not express any ideas and said ‘’ such matters have been said in your books, so study them.
There were a lot of struggles about the serial ‘’ Mokhtarname’’. Al-Zahra University, Zahedan, the channel ‘’al-Jazire’’ and other channels say every day ‘’ they acted impertinently toward Abdullah Ben Zobayr’’. If we find time, we will survey the file of Abdullah Ben Zobayr and see whether he is deserved to be defended or not? Abdullah Ben Zobayr prohibited to utter praise to the Muhammad and his descendants in the sermons of the Friday prayer and he said ‘’ I do not agree with this action and I do not want to utter praise to the Muhammad and his descendants because the prophet (peace be upon him and his descendants) إن له أهيل سوء has أهل سوئي. He acts impertinently toward the leader of the faithful (peace be upon him). Then, he has become a companion and he has been defended. We consider respect and value for the companions. We do not respect, insult, abuse and act impertinently toward the persons that stood against the prophet's family (peace be upon them) and the leader of the faithful (peace be upon) and we do not appreciate them. You have mentioned the Hoz Hadith in the most of the valid books. Hence, it is not appropriate to say that such and such a person is Naseby and we address all of people Naseby. You express matters scientifically and leave addressees to judge whether a person is Naseby or not. We narrated from Ebn Hajar Asghalani
النواصب الزاعمين أن عليا لم يكن مصيبا في حروبه
'’Naseby people believed that Imam Ali (peace be upon him) was not right and did wrongs in Jamal, Sefin and Khavarej Wars’’.
We called Sunni Molavi several times and even Molavi Morad Zehi came over here. Moreover, Several Sunni scholars said clearly ''we believe that Ali Ben Abi Taleb (peace be upon him) was right in all of his wars. However, we think that they did jihad and they made a mistake in their jihad''. They think in this way and I never see that even a Sunni person believes that the leader of the faithful (peace be upon him) was not right in the wars. Since they consider interest and affection to the companions, they say ''they did jihad and made a mistake in their jihad''. Moreover, they say'' if a person does jihad, he will achieve to his right and God will award him twice and if a person makes a mistake in jihad, God will award him once. We do not care about whether they did jihad or not and we have our own reasons. When the prophet (peace of Allah be upon him and his descendants) bade
عمار تقتله الفئة الباغية، عمار يدعوهم إلي الله و يدعونه إلي النار
'' The tyrants killed Amar and he invited them to worshiping God, but they invited Amar to fire''.
There is no chance for jihad in such a situation.
Question 8
I got satisfied about your remarks in relation to the idea of the Sunnite about the prophet's family (peace be upon them). We have never seen on any channels that the Shiite scholars talk clearly about the idea of the Sunnite toward the prophet's family (peace be upon them).
In response to the viewer that said '' all Sunnis recognized Israel '' I must say that you have the knowledge of the unseen about what happens inside the Sunni scientists. Didn't the Sunni scientists issue a blasphemy fatwa about Mr. Mobarak in surrounding Ghaze? Are abusing and cursing others accepted in the faith and the religion which Mr. Alayari does? Have Hazrat Ali (may God be well-pleased with him) or Imam Hussein (may God be well-pleased with him) and other Imams (may God be well-pleased with them) abused and cursed others?
We live in Zahedan, the Persians and the Baluchis, with the Shiite and Sunni people. We did not have any information about such matters at all a few years ago. We did not know what these programs are. We got married and had close relationships with each other. Even there were tribes that were Sunni and some of them were Shiite and there were good and devil between them. My mother made votive food in Ashura and Tasoa and distributed among people. The Sunnis do the same even now. To try to understand how the Sunnis remember the prophet's family (peace be upon them), Hazrat Ali (peace be upon him), Imam Hasan (peace be upon him) and Imam Hussein (peace be upon him) as سيدا شباب أهل الجنةand Hazrat Fateme Zahra (peace unto her) as سيدة نساء أهل الجنة. We utter praise to Muhammad and his descendants in our prayers and Daytan twenty four times in a day. I even asked the mufti of Zahedan about the optimal pray and he said '' one of the conditions is that you pray first, middle and last Daytan and utter praise to Muhammad and his descendants''.
Are telling realities that make people aware, provide affection among them and make close relationship among them considered treacherous and evil and wrong? Do they need to put them in question? I, as a Sunni scientist, that live in Zahedan consider a different personality for Mr. Alahyari from the Shiite community because I live with the Shiite people and know their ideas. In addition, they are my best friends and neighbors and I usually communicate with them. When we choose the names of Ali and Hasan for our children, they wonder whether we believe in Imam Ali (peace be upon him) to call your children with this name. In Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Chechnya and Palestine, Kashmir, etc, we were killed due to the crime of attestation word. Our religion, Prophet and dignitaries are insulted and they never ask whether you are Jafari, Shafei, Maliki ,Hanafi and Hanbeli…